| Apr. 30 |
Central Florida Kraze 1, Cocoa Expos 2 |
| Apr. 30 |
Southern California Seahorses 2, Nevada Wonders 3 |
| May 1 |
Sioux Falls Spitfire 3, Kansas City Brass 4 |
| May 1 |
Reading Rage 2, Brooklyn Knights 1 |
| May 2 |
Sioux Falls Spitfire 0, St. Louis Strikers 1 |
| May 7 |
Central Florida Kraze 3, Bradenton Academics 2 |
| May 7 |
West Virginia Chaos 0, Carolina Dynamo 1 |
| May 7 |
West Michigan Edge 3, Kalamazoo Kingdom 2 |
| May 7 |
Vermont Voltage 0, Brooklyn Knights 2 |
| May 7 |
Laredo Heat 1, Nashville Metros 3 |
| May 7 |
Lafayette Swamp Cats 0, Austin Lightning 4 |
| May 7 |
El Paso Patriots 1, Memphis Express 0 |
| May 7 |
New Orleans Shell Shockers 0, DFW Tornados 8 |
| May 7 |
Kansas City Brass 0, Colorado Springs Blizzard 4 |
| May 7 |
BYU Cougars 0, Orange County Blue Star 2 |
| May 8 |
New Jersey Stallions 0, Rhode Island Stingrays 3 |
| May 8 |
West Virginia Chaos 1, Raleigh CASL Elite 2 |
| May 8 |
Jersey Falcons 1, Cape Cod Crusaders 3 |
| May 8 |
Palm Beach Pumas 1, Cocoa Expos 8 |
| May 8 |
El Paso Patriots 2, Nashville Metros 1 |
| May 8 |
New Orleans Shell Shockers 1, Austin Lightning 1 |
| May 8 |
Laredo Heat 0, Memphis Express 4 |
| May 8 |
Cascade Surge 2, Abbotsford Rangers 1 |
| May 8 |
Yakima Reds 1, Spokane Shadow 2 |
| May 8 |
BYU Cougars 1, Southern California Seahorses 3 |
| May 9 |
Lafayette Swamp Cats 0, DFW Tornados 9 |
| May 9 |
Kansas City Brass 0, Boulder Rapids Reserve 2 |
| May 9 |
Rhode Island Stingrays 2, Brooklyn Knights 3 |
| May 9 |
Raleigh CASL Elite 1, Williamsburg Legacy 3 |
| May 13 |
Michigan Bucks 5, Indiana Invaders 0 |
| May 14 |
Raleigh CASL Elite 1, Richmond Kickers Future 1 |
| May 14 |
Ajax Orlando Prospects 1, Central Florida Kraze 3 |
| May 14 |
New Jersey Stallions 1, Albany Blackwatch Highlanders 2 |
| May 14 |
Chesapeake Dragons 1, Carolina Dynamo 4 |
| May 14 |
Toledo Slayers 0, Cleveland Internationals 3 |
| May 14 |
Fort Wayne Fever 5, Kalamazoo Kingdom 2 |
| May 14 |
Williamsburg Legacy 2, West Virginia Chaos 1 |
| May 14 |
Bradenton Academics 0, Cocoa Expos 1 |
| May 14 |
Boulder Rapids Reserve 6, Sioux Falls Spitfire 3 |
| May 14 |
Memphis Express 1, New Orleans Shell Shockers 0 |
| May 14 |
Colorado Springs Blizzard 2, Des Moines Menace 3 |
| May 14 |
Nevada Wonders 0, BYU Cougars 2 |
| May 14 |
Austin Lightning 0, El Paso Patriots 6 |
| May 14 |
Abbotsford Rangers 2, Cascade Surge 3 |
| May 14 |
Southern California Seahorses 2, Fresno Fuego 3 |
| May 15 |
Vermont Voltage 1, New Jersey Stallions 1 |
| May 15 |
Brooklyn Knights 0, South Jersey Barons 5 |
| May 15 |
Kalamazoo Kingdom 1, Cleveland Internationals 0 |
| May 15 |
Michigan Bucks 5, West Michigan Edge 1 |
| May 15 |
Memphis Express 2, Lafayette Swamp Cats 5 |
| May 15 |
Wisconsin Rebels 0, Chicago Fire Reserves 5 |
| May 16 |
Laredo Heat 0, DFW Tornados 4 |
| May 15 |
Nashville Metros 1, New Orleans Shell Shockers 2 |
| May 15 |
Boulder Rapids Reserve 3, Des Moines Menace 1 |
| May 15 |
Colorado Springs Blizzard 3, Sioux Falls Spitfire 3 |
| May 15 |
Indiana Blast 0, St. Louis Strikers 3 |
| May 15 |
Austin Lightning 1, El Paso Patriots 4 |
| May 15 |
Nevada Wonders 3, BYU Cougars 1 |
| May 15 |
Yakima Reds 1, Cascade Surge 4 |
| May 16 |
Williamsburg Legacy 0, Chesapeake Dragons 2 |
| May 16 |
Richmond Kickers Future 2, West Virginia Chaos 1 |
| May 16 |
Ajax Orlando Prospects 2, Bradenton Academics 1 |
| May 16 |
Indiana Blast 3, Kansas City Brass 2 |
| May 16 |
Chicago Fire Reserves 8, Wisconsin Rebels 0 |
| May 16 |
Albany Blackwatch Highlanders 1, South Jersey Barons 1 |
| May 16 |
Reading Rage 2, Jersey Falcons 1 |
| May 16 |
Central Florida Kraze 2, Palm Beach Pumas 0 |
| May 16 |
Orange County Blue Star 2, Fresno Fuego 1 |
| May 16 |
Spokane Shadow 3, Abbotsford Rangers 2 |
| May 18 |
Fort Wayne Fever 1, Michigan Bucks 1 |
| May 19 |
Cape Cod Crusaders 1, Albany Blackwatch Highlanders 0 |
| May 19 |
South Jersey Barons 2, Jersey Falcons 1 |
| May 19 |
West Michigan Edge 2, Indiana Invaders 4 |
| May 19 |
Chicago Fire Reserves 5, Indiana Blast 0 |
| May 20 |
Toledo Slayers 2, Fort Wayne Fever 3 |
| May 21 |
Spokane Shadow 3, Yakima Reds 2 |
| May 21 |
Carolina Dynamo 5, Richmond Kickers Future 3 |
| May 21 |
Des Moines Menace 5, Wisconsin Rebels 1 |
| May 21 |
DFW Tornados 3, El Paso Patriots 2 |
| May 21 |
St. Louis Strikers 3, Colorado Springs Blizzard 5 |
| May 22 |
Carolina Dynamo 2, Williamsburg Legacy 3 |
| May 22 |
South Jersey Barons 1, Cape Cod Crusaders 0 |
| May 22 |
Albany Blackwatch Highlanders 2, Reading Rage 1 |
| May 22 |
Rhode Island Stingrays 3, Vermont Voltage 1 |
| May 22 |
Richmond Kickers Future 3, Chesapeake Dragons 3 |
| May 22 |
Bradenton Academics 3, Palm Beach Pumas 0 |
| May 22 |
Kalamazoo Kingdom 2, Toledo Slayers 0 |
| May 22 |
West Michigan Edge 3, Cleveland Internationals 4 |
| May 22 |
Fresno Fuego 3, Southern California Seahorses 1 |
| May 22 |
Laredo Heat 1, Austin Lightning 1 |
| May 22 |
Abbotsford Rangers 2, Yakima Reds 1 |
| May 22 |
Cascade Surge 1, Spokane Shadow 3 |
| May 22 |
Central Florida Kraze 0, Ajax Orlando Prospects 2 |
| May 23 |
Jersey Falcons 1, Vermont Voltage 2 |
| May 23 |
Des Moines Menace 0, Chicago Fire Reserves 2 |
| May 23 |
Wisconsin Rebels 1, Indiana Blast 1 |
| May 23 |
Chesapeake Dragons 6, Raleigh CASL Elite 1 |
| May 23 |
Palm Beach Pumas 1, Ajax Orlando Prospects 9 |